Close ad

Although hundreds of comments have already been written about it, only a few people actually had it under their hands. We're talking about none other than the new MacBook Pro, which is stirring up a lot of passion, and most who write about it criticize Apple for practically everything it has done. Only now, however, are the first comments from people who have actually touched the new Apple iron with the innovative Touch Bar.

One of the first "reviews", or views of the new 15-inch MacBook Pro, posted on the web Huffington Post Thomas Grove Carter, who works as an editor at Trim Editing, a company that specializes in editing expensive commercials, music videos and films. So Carter considers himself a professional user in terms of what he uses the computer for and what demands he has on it.

Carter uses Final Cut Pro X for his daily work, so he was able to test the new MacBook Pro to its full potential, including the Touch Bar, which is already ready for Apple's editing tool.

First thing, he's really fast. I've been using a MacBook Pro with the new version of FCP X, cutting 5K ProRes material all week and it's been running like clockwork. Regardless of what you think of its specification, the fact is that the software and hardware are so well integrated that in real-world use it will crush its much better specced Windows competitors.

The model I was using was powerful enough on the graphics side to drive two 5K displays, which is an insane number of pixels. So I'm wondering if I could use this machine to cut twenty-four hours a day without any problems, both in the office and on the go. The answer is probably yes. (…) This machine made the already very fast editing software even faster.

Although some people don't like the internals like the processors or RAM in the new MacBook Pros, the connectors are even more of a concern, as Apple has removed all of them and replaced them with four USB-C ports, compatible with Thunderbolt 3. Carter doesn't have a problem with that, because now he is said to be using an external SSD with USB-C and is otherwise removing ports as he did in 2012. At that time he also bought a new MacBook Pro, which lost DVD, FireWire 800 and Ethernet.

According to Carter, it's only a matter of time before everything adapts to the new connector. Until then, he will probably just replace the Thunderbolt to MiniDisplay converters on his desk, which he used for older monitors anyway, for a Thunderbolt 3 dock.

But Carter's experience with the Touch Bar is key, because he is one of the first to describe it from what he has actually experienced, and it is not just the assumptions that the Internet is full of. Carter, too, was skeptical of the new MacBook control at first, but as he got used to the touchpad above the keyboard, he came to like it.

The first pleasant surprise for me was the potential of sliders. They are slow, precise and fast. (…) The more I used the Touch Bar, the more I replaced certain keyboard shortcuts with it. Why would I use two- and multi-finger shortcuts when there's a single button right in front of me? And it's contextual. It changes based on what I'm doing. When I edit an image, it shows me the relevant cropping shortcuts. When I edit the subtitles it shows me the font, formatting and colors. All this without having to open an offer. It works, it's faster and more productive.

Carter sees the future of the Touch Bar, saying that this is all just the beginning before all developers adopt it. Within a week of working with the Touch Bar in Final Cut, the Touch Bar quickly became part of his workflow.

Many professional users who use editing, graphic and other more advanced tools often object that they have no reason to replace dozens of keyboard shortcuts, which they have learned by heart over years of practice and work very quickly thanks to them, with a touch panel. Moreover, if they had to turn their eyes away from the work surface of the display. However, virtually none of them have tried the Touch Bar for more than a few minutes.

As Carter suggests, for example, the precision of the scrollbar can ultimately prove to be a very efficient matter, as this input can be much more accurate than moving the scrollbar with a cursor and a finger on a touchpad. More big reviews should probably appear before long, as Apple should already start delivering the first new models to customers.

It will be interesting to see how journalists and other reviewers approach the new MacBook Pros after a really big wave of negative reactions, but Thomas Carter has one very apt point to make:

This is a laptop. It's not an iMac. It's not a Mac Pro. Missing update these Macs should not influence the opinion of this Mac. Not clarifying the situation around other computers is a problem from Apple, but that's a completely different topic. Would we get so much backlash if the other machines were also updated? Probably not.

Carter is right that a lot of the backlash has included outrage that Apple has completely ditched loyal professional users, and the new MacBook Pros certainly aren't what should be enough for those users. Therefore, it will be interesting to see how the new machines will be demonstrated in real operation.

.