Close ad

One of the first Czechs to describe his experience with the new MacBook Pro with Touch Bar in more detail, is Michal Blaha. And it must be said that his verdict is not very positive. In the end, he returned the latest Apple computer to return to the older MacBook Air himself.

It is important to mention that Michal Blaha spends half of his time on the MacBook in macOS and half in Windows (virtualization via Parallels), where he uses various development tools.

I only used the new MacBook for two days. The Touch Bar highlights the fundamental differences between macOS and Windows. MacOS is controlled via keyboard shortcuts, you practically do not need the Fn keys (while in Windows you need them for basic keyboard shortcuts as well). That's why the Touch Bar makes a lot of sense on macOS.

(...)

When working in Windows, you cannot do without the Fn keys. When programming even more, Visual Studio, various editors, TotalCommander, all these applications have the most common keyboard shortcuts built on the Fn keys.

Blaha perfectly described the difference in the operating philosophy of the two operating systems and why Apple could quite easily deprive the new MacBook Pro of a whole range of function keys. But if you move around in Windows and actively use them on a Mac as well, you may have a big problem without function keys.

Touch Bar is a touch surface with a display, matte, without relief. It doesn't give any feedback on whether you touch (and trigger an action under your finger) or not. It has no haptic feedback.

Expecting some kind of response when you put your finger on the Touch Bar is logical. Myself, during my first interactions with the new MacBook Pro, I expected the touch strip to respond to me in some way. And that's mainly because in such cases, other Apple products react to me in a similar way.

Considering where Apple has already deployed haptic feedback, it can be expected that this is also the future of the Touch Bar, but for now it is unfortunately just a "dead" display. In the iPhone 7, the haptic response is highly addictive and we have also known it for a long time, for example, from trackpads in MacBooks.

But the haptic response in the Touch Bar would be good especially for the fact that it would not be necessary to monitor so often what you are actually doing with your finger. Now, a rather schizophrenic situation can arise many times, when you use the Touch Bar to control what is happening on the display, but at the same time you have to check with at least one eye if you are correct. Without relief or haptic feedback, you have no chance of knowing.

The Touch Bar is clearly just at the beginning and we can expect that Apple will improve it in terms of hardware and software, however, as Michal Blaha points out, already "the Touch Bar is almost genius for creative activities (editing photos, working with video)".

If the Touch Bar and its poor usability in Windows were the only reason, it would have taken Blaha much longer to decide, but there were many more reasons for handing in the new MacBook Pro: the three-year-old MacBook Air lasts longer on its battery, it lacks MagSafe, the rising price does not bring that much higher performance and So far, USB-C is rather confusing. As a final negative point, Blaha describes the "increasing UX inconsistency of Apple products":

– The iPhone 7 (which I have) uses a Lightning to USB connector for charging. I will not connect it to the MacBook without a reduction.

– iPhone 7 does not have a jack connector, and the headphones have a Lightning connector. The MacBook has a jack connector, it doesn't have a Lightning connector, and iPhone headphones won't fit into the MacBook even through the adapter. I have to wear two headphones, or a reduction from the jack to Lightning!

– Apple does not supply a full USB-C cable for fast data transfers with the MacBook Pro for 60 crowns. I have to buy another one for 000 crowns. WTF!!!

– Apple didn't give me a USB-C to Lightning cable for either the phone or the laptop so I could charge the iPhone from the laptop. WTF!!!

– If I put the MacBook on top of the iPhone 7, the MacBook goes to sleep. They think I closed the display. Cool :-(.

– Unlocking your MacBook Pro is fun when you're wearing an Apple Watch. You can write a password, unlock with a fingerprint (Touch ID is lightning fast) or wait for the MBP to unlock the Apple Watch.
TouchID can also be used for shopping, for many things in the system where a password must be entered (for example, to show saved logins in Safari), but the Apple Watch cannot be used for the same.

– Chaos in the MacBook Air (what will happen to it?), MacBook and MacBook Pro model lines and complete mystery as to what will happen next. I don't think they know.

Michal Blaha very aptly describes in a few brief points how many (at least for now) illogical decisions Apple has made recently. Many have already been discussed, such as the fact that you simply cannot connect headphones from the iPhone 7, which have Lightning, to any MacBook at all, and conversely, you have to use a dongle, or that you cannot connect an iPhone to a MacBook Pro without an additional cable at all.

But the most important is probably the last remark about the chaos in the model lines, when it is certainly not only Michal who is dealing with a big dilemma. For the time being, the place of the newest computer remains with the relatively old Air, which is not enough especially with the display, because, like everyone else, they have no idea what will actually happen with the other Apple laptops. The most viable path, which I myself took some time ago, seems to be to switch to the older MacBook Pro from 2015, which now comes out the best in terms of price / performance, but it is definitely not a good calling card for Apple if users will look more closely at after such elections.

But since other Apple laptops remain uncertain, we can't be surprised by customers. What will happen next with the MacBook - will it remain only in the 12-inch model, or will there be an even bigger one? Is the replacement for the MacBook Air really (and illogically) a MacBook Pro without a Touch Bar?

.